One night hans wants to start up their reading practice of the shoulder shrug again, but liesel is nervous about going into the basement. What does max s mother hand him before he escapes with walter. Although liesel is nervous meeting max at first, they quickly become good friends. In the book, the whistler gets thrown into the river when rudy finds out about max. They both love to read and write, they are both very curious people, and they have what sophie already pointed out. Differences between the book thief book vs movie page 0. He frequently fought a boy named walter kugler, and over the years they. Compare liesel and rudy in a venn diagram the book thief. We will compare and contrast liesel and max, and we will explain the significence of the story the standover man you could argue. Her soul, like her papas, sat up when death came for her, and as she went she thought of her three children, her grandchildren, her husband, and the many loved ones from her past, especially. The book thief was magically brought to life by 20th century fox. My book club discussed this book last night and we all gave it 5 stars. In the book thief, words have the power to both destroy and save lives.
The relationship of max and liesel by sharon lu on prezi. For max, simply surviving is an act of resistance against hitler. The similarities and differences of max and liesel the lark. Later, liesels descriptions of the weather outside to max also help to establish a bond between them. With one eye open, one still in a dream, the book thiefalso known as liesel. If it had been the whistler, the hubermanns secret would have been kept long after max safely escaped the basement. Perhaps the reason that these two characters gravitate towards each other is because of their incredible similarities. However, max vandenburg and liesel meminger went against this abomination during this time and during their friendship max vandenburg gave many things to liesel. Also, there is a scene when rudy goes back for liesel s shoes that were left at the mayors house when she was stealing from ilsas library. Many of the people living in molching believe that frau hermann is insane. He was the one who she knew was there for him when she first arrived to her foster home on himmel street.
What factors helped to create the bond between max and liesel. The idea of a jewish male and a german girl becoming good acquaintances is an unimaginable, punishable thought in the time that the book thief is written. The next time liesel is in the mayors library, ilsa hermann is especially insistent that she take the whistler, which liesel finally accepts. Differences between the book thief book vs movie page 1. This guy is a fighter in just about all the ways someone can be a fighter. Some of the differences about max and liesel are that liesel got away from being treated bad well somewhat.
Max repaints the pages of the book, mein kampf and gives it to liesel for her to write in it. The differences between the book thief book and the book. In the next couple slides we will answer the questions how does max s life give liesel purpose. When max and liesel have a joyful reunion, its almost like the jewish fighter is punching hitler right in the face.
The reality is that she is depressed over her sons death in. Max and liesel have both lost their families, and both have come to live with hans and rosa. Liesel, in the act of watching, was already noticing the similarities between this stranger and herself. Like liesel, he grew up unafraid to use his fists, and fought regularly with whoever would take him on. What similarities between herself and max does liesel recognize right away. She has fluffy hair and walks around in her bathrobe during the day. The book thief cliffsnotes study guides book summaries. Rudy sees max s name written on one of liesel s books and discovers the secret of max while he is still in the basement. In the book thief how is the relationship between liesel.
Another way they are similar is they are close to the same age, liesel being only 8 months younger than rudy. Liesel, in the act of watching, was already noticing the similarities between this. Despite just reading the first half of the book thief, similarities between the two have already been made evident to me. The friendship that develops between liesel and max is touching, heartwrenching, and extremely powerful. Max, like liesel, comes to the story fresh from experiencing great loss. What are some of the similarities between liesel and max. Did anyone else notice the stark similarities between these two. Rudy finds out about max after he has left the basement. Max came to the hubermanns and at first liesel was kept away from max, which caused her to be very confused about his presence.
Max vandenburg arrived on himmel street carrying handfuls of suffering and. He states that the book thief died only yesterday, that she lived a long life in a place far away from munich and himmel street in a suburb of sydney. Schindlers list is also a very dark viewpoint but is equally as good as the book thief. In the film, it was the blank book max had given liesel. Originally, when liesel and max first met, they were quite apprehensive towards one another. Zusak 161 max on the other hand had to go into hiding not seeing daylight in a long time always with a fear that someone would find him and take him away. And while it may seem like i thought the movie was complete rubbish, that is. The basement was the only place for him as far as he was concerned. The story of book thief is about liesel meminger and is told by the death, who is haunted by humans. Lets discuss how liesel and max s experiences are really not all that different. It was adapted into a 20 feature film of the same name. Max and liesel have so many similarities, you could guess they were related. The standover man and the word shaker are two books that max vanderburg, the jewish fugitive, writes for liesel, the german girl, in the book thief.
Get an answer for in the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max. On what pretext does rosa come to the school to tell liesel max has awakened. When liesel moved to 33 himmelstreet rudy became her next door neighbour. And while it may seem like i thought the movie was complete rubbish, that is really only in comparison to the original text. In the movie max dreams of becoming a boxer and fighting hitler. So, we think a good way to analyze liesel s character. In the book thief did liesel marry max vandenburgh answers. The big discussion topic was whether or not liesel and max got married in the end. Nazi soldiers arrive and inspect the basement to see if it is deep enough for a bomb shelter. I do not own any of the movie clips, all rights go to fox and markus zusak.
During the period of time that he hid in the hubermanns home, max and liesel became friends. Study 55 terms the book thief study guide flashcards. Unfortunately max must hide in their basement cellar. However, in the movie, liesel actually goes as far as to tell rudy about hiding max.
Besides the common narrator, death in both novels is portrayed as someonesomething that is agreeable, but not necessarily nice. The story flashes back once again, to tell the history of max vandenburg. Liesels purpose contrast liesel s purpose max liesel comparison max is an inspiration max writes stories for liesel has a friend 247 learned from each other max gives liesel courage liesel relates to max both went through similar life look out for each other shows her the real. When we first meet max, he is in a train coming to molching, with a notecard with hans hermans information, who apparently knew max s father in the war. Bonding over nightmares, both the feeling of guilt, both found comfort in hans home etc. Other similarities not yet noted are the characters of max and tom both being victims of the settings of the novels. In the book of the book thief, liesel meminger learns through various ways that the nazi party is inimical. These are just a few of the differences between the book and movie versions of the book thief. In the movie the hand painted mein kampf gets thrown into the river.
Both of the books titles are actually titles for liesel herself. In the movie of the book thief, she walks silently away. The standover man, the word shaker maimstream englitch. One way they are similar is because they both enjoy some of the same activities, like soccer and stealing. Write notes about two possible topics for your essay from those suggested below power of language one option.
They finally go down, and hans sees that max is freezing and emaciated. He was staying place to place or more, storage unit to basements without a family, without any hope really. According to death, liesel s book, the book thief, is divided in this way as well. Get an answer for in the book thief how is the relationship between liesel and rudy like family, lovers, strangers, and enemies. Max vandenburg promised that he would never sleep in liesel s room again. After the war ends and the jews are freed, max goes back to find liesel, and they are. What does max believe are the two most pitiful words he can say. Max has to stay in hiding, whereas, liesel moves freely.
Over the course of the novel, she befriends max, the jew who arrives to hide from the nazis in the hubermanns basement, and falls in love with rudy steiner, her best friend. For instance, during liesel s nightmares about her brother, death told us that possibly. Thief, zusak limits his unnatural narrator to the narrative abilities of a natural. When reading the book, i only felt as if max and liesel were good friends.
The story, narrated by death himself, follows a young girl as she arrives in a small town in germany to live with her new foster parents as ww2 looms. Besides from some obvious differences as gender, nationalities, and age. Liesel is traumatized by her brothers death, but hans proves to be a calming foster father. Narration in markus zusaks the book thief the aquila digital. Markus zusaks the book thief and its use of narrative empathy. At first his age is a bit surprising, because he almost seems like an old man. The characters liesel meminger and rudy stiener are very similar in many ways. Now, she is reading the whistler rosa and hans make liesel deliver food to max in the basement.
The book thief is a historical novel by australian author markus zusak and is his most popular work. Published in 2005, the book thief became an international bestseller and was translated into 63 languages and sold 16 million copies. Liesel and max have both lost families, they have both gained new parents in the character of hans and rosa, they each. In june of 1941, germany invades the soviet union, and liesel and max see the mayor in the newspaper telling people to prepare for hard times. Although one was a jewish fist fighter and one was a german book thief, max and liesel soon saw that they had things in common.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Liesel had connections with many people throughout the book thief, but i felt the strongest connection was to hans huberman, also known as her papa. This passage demonstrates the similarities between hitlers political. What threats does hans make to instill in liesel the importance of keeping max secret. The hubermanns decide that max will sleep upstairs and then return to the basement during the day, and they start to form a routine. Examine how characters in the novel for example, liesel, max, ilsa hermann, hitler, rosa andor hans use words to destroy and to save. He rationalized that he was so bewildered upon his arrival that he allowed such a thing. With narration being a major focal point of the novel, liesel finds salvation. I like how you wrote about their similarities and their differences.
The relationship between liesel and max changed and developed throughout the course of the book thief. In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of. The greatest gift max gives liesel in the novel is words in. The friendship between liesel and max in the last 100 pages that we have read, i must say that the friendship between max and liesel is one of the more important parts of the book. Both have left their respective families and have been adopted by the hubermans. From the book to the movie, there have been many changes in characters too. Liesel s outside life progresses as it has been she walks with rudy, picks up and delivers the washing, and reads in the mayors library. In the movie, though, max is reading a newspaper and dismally says that germany is winning the war. She lives at 8 grande strasse and gets to know liesel because rosa does the mayors washing and ironing. The book thief book vs film with a book as beloved as markus zusaks the book thief, an adaptation was always going to be a challenge.
I have only read one other book which is from the perspective of death, and that book is called keturah and lord death by martine leavitt. Well look at how she grows and changes between 1939 and 1943 by looking at what each of the books mean to her. Although it does say she gets married and has children, max is not mentioned, so we can conclude that liesel. He also feels ashamed of the burden he places on the hubermanns since he knows hes putting them in serious danger by being in their home. The book thief is a relatively easy read told from a single point of view which happens to be death. The book thief the relationship between liesel and max.
Max is in hiding because he is jewish liesel s father was a member of the communist party, who had a falling out when the nazi regime took control. I read the book thief and am wondering what are some good compare and contrast points when looking at max and liesel. Back in the present, max, who is eriks son and now 24, is let in to the hubermanns house. Set during nazi germany in world war ii, political unrest is shown throughout markus zusaks novel, the book thief. Besides from some obvious differences as gender, nationalities, and age, they also have very different minds. Comparecontrast liesel meminger and max vandenburg max vandenburg was a jew in hiding in the 1940s. The book that was thrown into the river in the novel, was a book liesel had stolen to read to max. When the idea of a thief comes to mind one does not think of a book thief, but that is the description of liesel meminger. He feels deeply guilty for leaving his family to save himself, an act he sees as a choice rather than a necessity to survive. Liesel meminger, the eponymous book thief, who is a young girl growing up in nazi.